JavaFX: Play a sound when ever something is clicked

I currently have my EventHandler here:

theScene.setOnMouseClicked(
            new EventHandler<MouseEvent>() {
                public void handle(MouseEvent e) {
                    if (targetData.containsPoint(e.getX(), e.getY())) {
                        double x = 50 + 400 * Math.random();
                        double y = 50 + 400 * Math.random();
                        targetData.setCenter(x, y);
                        mediaPlayer.play(); //play hitsound
                        points.value++; //add points
                    } else {
                        points.value = 0; //miss
                    }
                }
            });

I also have my audio setup like so:

    String hitNormal = ("hit.mp3");
    Media sound = new Media(new File(hitNormal).toURI().toString());
    MediaPlayer mediaPlayer = new MediaPlayer(sound);

When I run my program, only the first click on the circle plays the hitsound, but all the following circles do not play the sound. I think what I have above should work since every time I click additional circles it always adds score. Since I have my mediaPlayer.play(); in the exact same if statement as the line that adds score, I expected the sound to play as well. How do I get my hitsound to play every time I click the circle?

EDIT: I added mediaPlayer.stop(); under points.value++ and it seems to occasionally play the hitsound but not always.